News | National
22 Nov 2024 2:56
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • Crime.co.nz
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > National

    Firearms law reform: the case for making club membership compulsory for NZ gun owners

    Proposed changes to gun laws aimed at reducing compliance costs for clubs and shooting ranges won’t necessarily drive up memberships – which is key to improving public safety.

    Alexander Gillespie, Professor of Law, University of Waikato
    The Conversation


    The rationale behind the coalition government’s proposed reform of New Zealand’s gun laws sounds reasonable on the face of it. Responsible gun owners, shooting ranges and clubs deserve a sensible legal framework and a viable financial footing.

    But the Arms (Shooting Clubs, Shooting Ranges, and Other Matters) Amendment Bill, currently before the justice select committee, arguably goes about it the wrong way.

    In particular, reducing compliance costs for clubs and ranges will not automatically increase memberships or make such organisations more financially viable.

    However, making club membership compulsory for gun owners would.

    Comparable jurisdictions such as Australia – and New South Wales in particular – use specialised club memberships and attendance at mandatory events as evidence of licence applicants having a “genuine reason” to possess firearms.

    The role of clubs and ranges

    Whatever its eventual shape, the new legislation will affect many people. As of mid-2024, there were just over 232,000 licensed owners in New Zealand, down from more than 240,000 just a couple of years ago.

    There were 1,184 shooting ranges and 396 shooting clubs, of which 303 were non-pistol clubs. Many of these have strong historical, social and cultural foundations, and deliver significant benefits to members, including building skills, confidence and safety awareness.

    They are also often run by volunteers and operate on limited budgets. Making them commercially viable is a sensible part of an overall gun safety strategy.

    But only an estimated 20,000–40,000 people are affiliated with shooting clubs. Compulsory membership only applies to those with legal endorsements to possess pistols, with participation in 12 club shooting activities per year required.

    Non-pistol owners who want a licence are required to pass a three-and-a-half-hour safety course. Whether this is sufficient to cover the fundamental safety considerations is questionable.

    There are no obligatory followup courses or a practical live-firing shooting component. By comparison, a prospective gun owner in Japan must attend mandatory all-day classes and pass written and shooting-range tests with an accuracy of at least 95%.

    Viable clubs and ranges are a sensible part of an overall gun safety strategy. Getty Images

    Convincing the public

    A little lateral thinking might help square the circle. Making membership of clubs and ranges mandatory for most, and introducing practical components to the licensing and renewal system, would drive up member numbers and income.

    As well, facilitating the creation of new clubs – inclusive, specialised, geographically well placed, attractive to a younger generation – would help grow a responsible gun ownership culture.

    But for the public to support such initiatives, they will need to be convinced safety is being improved. The fact the terrorist behind the 2019 Christchurch atrocity received training at an established rifle club does not help.

    At the other end of the scale, a catalogue of 267 improvement notices issued to operators of clubs and ranges for not meeting prescribed standards has also not inspired confidence.

    Changes to the Arms Act made after the Christchurch attacks aimed to tilt the balance more towards public safety. The reforms affected licensing, the prohibition of the some types of firearms, and oversight of clubs and ranges.

    Clubs were required to have formal management and improved governance structures. The Firearms Safety Authority/Te Tari Pureke was responsible for certification, stricter enforcement, inspections and compliance. New national standards, such as the Police Shooting Range Manual, all helped.

    Unanswered questions

    The government, and particularly the Associate Minister of Justice (Firearms) Nicole McKee, need to explain how watering down of any of these rules – especially around reduced inspections or uniform national standards – will improve public safety.

    Five questions stand out.

    1. What are the safeguards to prevent people training in firearms use if they present a threat to public safety? Since 2021, those with firearms prohibition orders against them have been banned from membership of a shooting club or attending any shooting range. But only 30 such orders (eight of which were to gang members) had been issued in the first 15 months of the law taking effect.

    2. Should the same rule to apply to others who don’t meet the prohibition threshold, but have still had licences revoked, or to those deemed unfit (such as gang members or extremists)?

    3. Should the owners or managers of clubs and ranges be obliged to report worrying behaviour to the authorities? The Security Intelligence Service’s guide for identifying signs of violent extremism could be useful here.

    4. Should only registered firearms be allowed to be used at clubs and ranges?

    5. And what obligations should be placed on clubs and ranges to help reduce self-harm, the biggest firearms risk in New Zealand. By building awareness of mental health warning signs, such education and guidance could help gun communities protect vulnerable members.

    Law change offers an opportunity to improve gun safety and education. As things stand, however, reform risks reducing public safety while failing to secure the future of clubs and ranges.

    The Conversation

    Alexander Gillespie is a recipient of a Borrin Foundation Justice Fellowship to research comparative best practice in the regulation of firearms. He is also a member of the Ministerial Arms Advisory Group. The views expressed here are his own and not to be attributed to either of these organisations. He has submitted on this subject to the select committee examining reform of part 6 of the Arms Act.

    This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license.
    © 2024 TheConversation, NZCity

     Other National News
     21 Nov: There's serious injuries... after two vehicles collided on State Highway One, near Palmerston North
     21 Nov: A person has serious injuries after a crash between a car and motorbike in Marotiri, northwest of Taupo
     21 Nov: A Southland doctor has laid bare the reality of rural dementia care
     21 Nov: Gaza: outlook for Palestinians bleak under a Trump presidency that looks set to go ‘all the way’ with Netanyahu
     21 Nov: Concerns for a hiker overdue tramping near Queenstown
     21 Nov: A Head Hunters associate faces serious charges after a rampage in east Auckland last night
     21 Nov: Entropy and information control: the key to understanding how to mount the fightback against Trump and other populists
     Top Stories

    RUGBY RUGBY
    Former Canterbury representative Blair Murray will start at fullback for Wales in Sunday's test against South Africa in Cardiff More...


    BUSINESS BUSINESS
    New Zealanders can now make contactless payments entirely on iPhones More...



     Today's News

    Law and Order:
    Accusations of evidence planting, false statements, and acting in the Defence cross examinations at the murder trial of Tingjung Cao  21:57

    Entertainment:
    Scott Mills feels honoured to be replacing Zoe Ball as the host of BBC Radio 2's 'Breakfast Show' 21:39

    Motoring:
    There's serious injuries... after two vehicles collided on State Highway One, near Palmerston North 21:17

    Entertainment:
    Fiona Shaw insists "the dial is turning" for women in television 21:09

    Law and Order:
    Illegal immigrant gets life sentence for murder of Laken Riley highlighted by Donald Trump campaign 21:07

    Entertainment:
    A New York priest who let Sabrina Carpenter film her 'Feather' music video in his church has been stripped of his duties 20:39

    Entertainment:
    Barry Keoghan began enjoying life more when he stopped "making excuses for stuff" 20:09

    Entertainment:
    Ben Affleck thinks movies will be "one of the last things" to be replaced by AI 19:39

    Entertainment:
    Cynthia Erivo was "annoyed" by Dax Shepard's "inappropriate" question about her long nails 19:09

    Accident and Emergency:
    A person has serious injuries after a crash between a car and motorbike in Marotiri, northwest of Taupo 18:57


     News Search






    Power Search


    © 2024 New Zealand City Ltd