News | International
17 Apr 2025 21:26
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • Crime.co.nz
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > International

    New Zealand's controversial Treaty Principles Bill defeated in parliament as all but one party blocks its path forward

    New Zealand's Treaty Principles Bill has been voted down in the country's parliament, killing off the controversial piece of proposed legislation.


    The controversial Treaty Principles Bill which sought to redefine New Zealand's founding document has been voted down in a highly anticipated day in the country's parliament. 

    The bill needed a simple majority to pass its second reading, but failed with 112 votes against and just the 11 members of the ACT Party voting for it. 

    Of the six parties in the chamber, five voted against the bill, including the prime minister's party. 

    As the bill died, the chamber erupted into celebration, from both the floor and gallery, before those present broke into a waiata, or song. 

    Throughout the session, Speaker Gerry Brownlee tried to maintain control, scolding members of the public and ejecting one man from the gallery.    

    In his speech to the chamber, architect of the bill and ACT Party leader David Seymour said he would "fight on". 

    He challenged those who opposed the bill to explain how society was "supposed to work without clear rules that apply equally to all". 

    The Treaty is an agreement signed by more than 500 Maori chiefs and representatives of the Crown in 1840 as New Zealand was founded. 

    Over the past five decades, it has been central to enshrining Maori rights in law and a series of principles have been developed over time to help that process. 

    Mr Seymour's position that the current interpretation of the treaty affords Maori more rights than non-Maori New Zealanders has been addressed throughout two years of debate on this issue, and was answered again today. 

    "What is most offensive is the way that the ACT Party and the political right have twisted the narrative to fit a racist agenda. It is and always has been about legal rights Maori have in their contract with the Crown," Willie Jackson, leader of the Labour Maori caucus said. 

    Former prime minister and Labour leader Chris Hipkins told the chamber, the Coalition had helped "spread the myth of Maori privilege" and called Mr Seymour's bill "a stain on this country". 

     Maori Party member Hana Rawhiti Maipe Clarke, who led a haka during the first reading of the bill in November, said this process has proven New Zealand was not divided on this issue. 

    "This bill has been absolutely annihilated," she said. 

    "We had two choices: to live to or to die, we chose to live."

    Green Party co-leader Marama Davidson, whose party did not support the bill, made the same observation. 

    "The Treaty Principles Bill is dead. Our movement for Te Tiriti o Waitangi (Treaty of Waitangi) justice lives on,” she said. 

    "Instead of dividing and conquering, this bill has backfired and united communities across the motu (country) in solidarity for our founding agreement and what it represents."

    PM not present for vote 

    It was widely expected that the bill would fail as it did not have support within the governing coalition and faced fierce backlash from opposition parties and in the community.

    The bill has sparked a series of nationwide protests, including one in November when 40,000 people marched on parliament. 

    When the Treaty Principles Bill was opened for submissions earlier in the year, the select committee received about 300,000 responses, with the overwhelming majority opposing the proposal.  

    Prime Minister Christopher Luxon was not present for the second reading of the bill — one he agreed to support up until this point as part of a coalition agreement.

    New Zealand is governed by a three-party coalition of National, New Zealand First and David Seymour's ACT Party. 

    Seymour campaigned on taking a redefining of the Treaty of Waitangi to a referendum, but the house has denied him that option this time around. 

    After his bill was defeated today, Mr Seymour was asked about next steps. 

    "The basic commitment that ACT has to equal rights to all Kiwis before the law because that is a universal truth," he told New Zealand radio station NewstalkZB.  

    "As the election approaches, we will lay out how we're going to do that tactically. 

    "As we do all of this, I think we'll be asking how we can we get more people on board." 

    Asked if he would make a referendum a "bottom line" in future coalition negotiations, Mr Seymour said: "that is absolutely a possibility, we wouldn't rule that out." 

    At the 2023 election, the ACT Party garnered 8.6 per cent of the party vote.  

    [YouTube Foreign Correspondent]

    © 2025 ABC Australian Broadcasting Corporation. All rights reserved

     Other International News
     17 Apr: NSW Waratahs lose Super Rugby Women's Champions final 36-5 against Auckland Blues in appalling conditions
     17 Apr: Why on earth would Russia want a military base in Indonesia?
     17 Apr: King Charles's Easter message focuses on war, 'kindness' and heroism ahead of annual church service
     17 Apr: Scientists claim they've discovered most promising 'hints' of potential for life on distant planet
     17 Apr: Why is India's largest wildlife rescue facility threatening to sue conservationists?
     17 Apr: Why there's never been an NRL debut like what Lewis Dodd will face on Good Friday
     17 Apr: No end in sight for Birmingham's 'disgusting' rat and rubbish nightmare as bin strike continues
     Top Stories

    RUGBY RUGBY
    NSW Waratahs lose Super Rugby Women's Champions final 36-5 against Auckland Blues in appalling conditions More...


    BUSINESS BUSINESS
    Why is India's largest wildlife rescue facility threatening to sue conservationists? More...



     Today's News

    Rugby:
    NSW Waratahs lose Super Rugby Women's Champions final 36-5 against Auckland Blues in appalling conditions 21:17

    Law and Order:
    Double Murderer Mark Lundy will be released from prison despite his insistence that he never killed his wife and daughter 21:17

    Entertainment:
    Ellen Pompeo will not leave 'Grey's Anatomy' because it would "make no sense, emotionally or financially" 21:01

    Entertainment:
    Jessica Biel still feels embarrassed by her '7th Heaven' audition 20:31

    Entertainment:
    Alec Baldwin's daughter once plunged the annual Rockefeller Plaza Christmas tree lighting ceremony into chaos 20:01

    International:
    Why on earth would Russia want a military base in Indonesia? 19:47

    Entertainment:
    Christina Ricci has opened up about getting a creepy picture aged 11 from a "pervert" after a series of prank calls she and her friends made to a salesman 19:31

    International:
    King Charles's Easter message focuses on war, 'kindness' and heroism ahead of annual church service 19:07

    Entertainment:
    Ben Affleck is as bad at flirting as his uptight character in 'The Accountant 2' 19:01

    Environment:
    About 10 thousand homes are without power in Northland as crews work to turn the lights back on 18:57


     News Search






    Power Search


    © 2025 New Zealand City Ltd