News | Features
17 Aug 2022 22:07
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > Business > Features

    Fund Performance Tables can do More Harm than Good

    Some figures I saw recently strengthened my resolve to steer people away from KiwiSaver performance comparisons.

    Before anti-KiwiSavers leap in and say, “Hey, your last column was about KiwiSaver. Enough!”, let me add that this column also applies to comparisons of other managed funds.

    But given KiwiSaver’s popularity, it was inevitable that various organisations would put together performance comparisons that the news media would highlight. Not me, though, for several reasons:

    • Often, not every provider is included. And some of the smaller, excluded ones might well be particularly good.

    • Unless the numbers show returns after fees, they don’t mean much. Who needs great performance if a big chunk of your return goes to the fund managers? Even when after-fees numbers are used, providers can define fees differently.

    • The numbers may not always be accurate. I’ve heard rumblings that some providers might manipulate their numbers to put them in a better light. I can’t prove it, but it’s a worry.

    • The periods are too short. Everyone is in KiwiSaver for at least five years, often much longer. And returns on long-term investments, typically in riskier assets, vary wildly in the short term – leading some investors to panic and bail out, to their detriment.

    • Most importantly, even if all of the above problems were solved, past performance is not a guide to future performance.

    This is where the research comes in. Global firm Lipper Analytical Services listed the 20 best performing US share funds in the ten years ending December 1998, and then checked their performance in the following ten years, ending December 2008.

    Out of 2,322 funds, the top three in the previous decade came 1,485th, 1,977th and 1,991th. The average rank of the top 20 was 1,745th. Eight out of the 20 funds were in the bottom 11 per cent. In other words, most were dogs.

    Three funds weren’t quite so bad, coming 208th, 620th and 767th in the following decade. Still, that’s nothing to write home about.

    There is considerable debate over whether this would apply in New Zealand. But even if the results were much less stark here, I think New Zealanders would be foolish to assume a top local fund will stay at the top.

    So, if KiwiSaver providers can’t be helpfully judged by past performance, how should they be selected?

    For a start, choose a provider that offers the right sort of fund for you in terms of riskiness and international exposure, and perhaps also ethical investing. Some providers offer funds in which risk is automatically reduced as you get older, which might appeal to you.

    It’s a great idea to go for low fees, perhaps using the KiwiSaver fee calculator on And choose a provider whose communications make sense to you. Check websites to get an idea of this, and ask providers to mail information to you to sample.

    Other considerations might include whether the provider is New Zealand or internationally owned. Or you might want to know whether the boss belongs to his or her own scheme. If you are a non-employee, you might find that not all providers will accept the contribution pattern you prefer, so shop around for that.

    Once you consider all the factors that matter to you, you’ll probably find one provider emerges as your top choice. If you are already with a different provider, contact the new one, who will take care of the switch for you. For more on all this, see my book “The Complete KiwiSaver.”

    © 2022 Mary Holm, NZCity

     Other Features News
     10 Sep: Spring clean your finances
     13 Aug: Plan ahead to give yourself a debt-free Christmas!
     10 Jul: Wise up to clear credit card debt
     07 May: Ways to prepare for the unexpected
     30 Mar: Time for a financial progress check
     10 Feb: Studying up on NZ Super
     10 Jan: Managing the back-to-school bills
     Top Stories

    NZR boss Mark Robinson is welcoming the elevation of Joe Schmidt's role within the All Blacks More...

    The biggest jump in median weekly earnings since records began ... haven't closed the gender pay gap More...

     Today's News

    The Prime Minister insists there's a way back into Labour's good books for Gaurav Sharma  21:49

    Michelle Branch has reportedly filed for divorce from her estranged husband Patrick Carney and is said to be requesting custody of their children and child support 21:42

    Cars at a scrap metal yard in Christchurch have gone up in flames 21:19

    Nicholas Evans, the much-loved writer of 'The Horse Whisperer', is dead aged 72 after suffering a heart attack 21:12

    Living & Travel:
    The Loop: Scott Morrison dismisses calls to resign, the NSW flood inquiry's urgent recommendations, and a dog's amazing cave rescue 21:09

    Johnny Depp is set to direct his first film in 25 years, about an artist who died broke 20:42

    The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge will reportedly not have their long standing live-in nanny at their new downsized home 20:12

    Anne Heche will receive an Honour Walk after being taken off life support nine days after she was critically injured in a fiery car crash 19:42

    Hollywood legend Gina Lollobrigida will run for Senate in Italy's election next month 19:12

    NZR boss Mark Robinson is welcoming the elevation of Joe Schmidt's role within the All Blacks 18:59

     News Search

    Power Search

    © 2022 New Zealand City Ltd