News | Features
11 Aug 2022 11:39
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > Business > Features

    The Investor: Students Fail at Stock Picking, but Learn the Important Lesson

    The students in a university financial literacy course that I teach are lousy at picking stocks. But that doesn’t matter. Hopefully in the course of the “Stock Picking Game” they learn plenty.

    At the start of the semester I give the students one-page backgrounders from a stockbroker of about 25 New Zealand shares. I ask them to choose a share they think will perform well over the next 14 weeks. I also assign another share to each student, and put them into one of five portfolios of five shares.

    The day of reckoning is the last lecture of the semester. And this year it was a rude shock for some. Air New Zealand - the second most popular share, chosen by 56 of the 350 students - came dead last. Its return over the period, including dividends, was minus 14 per cent, perhaps because of rising fuel prices.

    Meanwhile, the best-performing share, NZX, which was chosen by just three students, produced an astonishing return of 55 per cent.

    Other popular shares also performed badly. The favourite was Fletcher Building, whose 3 per cent performance ranked 20th of 25. And third favourite, Auckland International Airport, ranked 18th.

    Small wonder that when I asked for a show of hands on whose share had performed better than the one I had assigned to them, only about a third of the class responded.

    I hastened to tell the students that in other years it was closer to half, which is what you would expect if you believe – as I do – that stock picking is basically a game of luck. This year the students had unusually bad luck.

    But the main point of the lesson was not about picking shares but about diversification.

    When we looked at the performance of the five portfolios, they ranged from 1 per cent to 22 per cent – a much narrower range than the minus
    14 to 55 per cent for the single shares. And for the “whole class portfolio” of 25 shares, the return was comfortably in the middle, at
    9 per cent.

    The message? The more shares you invest in, the less the total volatility, because the good offset the bad and vice versa. Sure, you miss out on the big highs. But research shows that most people are willing to do that if they also miss the big lows.

    There was, though, one concern with this year’s results. I didn’t want students to go away with the idea that a three-month share investment usually brings in around 9 per cent. I had already told them that you really need ten or more years to invest in shares. But would they forget that?

    Fortunately, I had to look no further than the previous year’s results to make my point. In that semester, the single share returns ranged from minus 29 to 6 per cent, the portfolios ranged from minus 8 to zero per cent, and the whole class portfolio returned minus 4 per cent. Not pretty.

    I also showed students how different the three-month and ten-year returns can be for a given share. Air New Zealand, for example, averaged nearly 13 per cent a year over the last ten years, and Fletcher Building averaged more than 20 per cent. Their recent performances were far from typical.

    Lesson done, I had just one problem. Most of the chocolate fish I had taken along as prizes for the clever share pickers were not awarded.

    I had to resort to giving booby prizes for all those Air New Zealand fans.

    © 2022 Mary Holm, NZCity

     Other Features News
     10 Sep: Spring clean your finances
     13 Aug: Plan ahead to give yourself a debt-free Christmas!
     10 Jul: Wise up to clear credit card debt
     07 May: Ways to prepare for the unexpected
     30 Mar: Time for a financial progress check
     10 Feb: Studying up on NZ Super
     10 Jan: Managing the back-to-school bills
     Top Stories

    South Africa will start with hooker Joseph Dweba in Saturday's second Rugby Championship Test against New Zealand after Bongi Mbonambi withdrew due to a knee injury picked up in training More...

    Gas users and experts call for federal crackdown on east coast 'gas cartel' More...

     Today's News

    Hamish Kerr has become the first New Zealand high jumper to reach the podium at a Diamond League meet with third in Monaco - he cleared 2.25 metres 11:19

    Gas users and experts call for federal crackdown on east coast 'gas cartel' 11:19

    Law and Order:
    A Marlborough woman likely drowned after taking hallucinogenic drugs 11:09

    Donald Trump is "furious yet scared" after the FBI raided Mar A Lago 10:49

    Law and Order:
    A man with Nomad gang links has been arrested after a fleeing driving incident in Invercargill 10:49

    Global uncertainty is continuing to affect KiwiSaver balances 10:29

    Jennette McCurdy wants Ariana Grande to read her new memoir, 'I'm Glad My Mom Died' 10:19

    Anthony Albanese says Australia is the largest non-NATO contributor to Ukraine. Is that correct? 10:09

    The average house price has fallen for the first time in 11 years 10:09

    Jane Lynch isn't pulling out of 'Funny Girl' on Broadway to avoid Lea Michele 9:49

     News Search

    Power Search

    © 2022 New Zealand City Ltd