News | Features
15 Aug 2022 2:46
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > Business > Features

    The Investor: Tax Deductions Not All They’re Sometimes Cracked Up To Be

    A comment I overheard from a young man recently worried me. Talking about some kind of investment in race horses, and he said, "I put in $1000 a month. But I can deduct $800, so it's hardly costing me anything."

    That's not correct. But from other comments and letters, I get the feeling he's not alone, that many people misunderstand how tax deductions affect investing.

    Here's a little test. Which would you prefer?:

    • An investment that brings in $10,000 a year, with tax deductible expenses of $5000.

    • An investment that brings in $7000 a year, with tax deductible expenses of $1000.

    The first one might look more attractive. The income is higher, and the deductions are bigger. But after you deduct the $5000, you're left with $5000 of taxable income.

    With the second investment, you're left with $6000 of taxable income. You have to pay tax on that, but you still have more money after tax.

    Another key point: with a tax deduction, you spend a lot more than you get back as a tax break.

    Let's say your taxable income is $60,000, which means you are in the 30 per cent tax bracket. If you spend $1000 on something deductible, that is subtracted from the $60,000 to give you taxable income of $59,000.

    Without the deduction, you would have paid 30 per cent tax - or $300 - on that last $1000 of income. With the deduction, you spent $1000 and cut your tax by $300. You're still out of pocket by $700.

    It looks a bit more favourable, in a way, if your taxable income is more than $70,000 - but only because you pay more tax. You are in the 33 per cent tax bracket. So spending $1000 on something deductible would cut your tax by $330. It still costs you $670.

    And if your taxable income is between $14,001 and $48,000, you are in the 17.5 per cent tax bracket. Spending $1000 would cut your tax by just $175. It would still cost you $825.

    This is where I think our young man misunderstood the situation. He seemed to think his investment was costing him only $200 a month.

    But if, for example, he's in the 30 per cent tax bracket, the $800 deduction will cut his tax by $240. He's handing over $1000 a month, and after tax that costs him $760 - much more than he realizes. I hope those horses win.

    A more common investment in which tax misunderstandings often figure is rental property.

    You sometimes hear landlords say it doesn't really matter if their rates or insurance rise, because they can deduct those expenses. They don't seem to realise that they still pay the bulk of that money, after tax.

    What's more, landlords sometimes brag about how their property is operating at a loss - because mortgage payments, rates, insurance and maintenance exceed the rent coming in - and they can deduct that loss from their other income.

    Well whoop-dee-do! They are still suffering losses. The only way such an investment can be worth doing is if they later sell the property for a higher price than they bought it for. And it has to be quite a lot higher.

    The extra money they've put in over the years - after taking into account the value of the tax deduction - could have been earning compounding interest elsewhere. The gain must more than offset that.

    If I were a landlord in this situation, I'd go soft on the bragging, and keep an anxious eye on house price trends.

    © 2022 Mary Holm, NZCity

     Other Features News
     10 Sep: Spring clean your finances
     13 Aug: Plan ahead to give yourself a debt-free Christmas!
     10 Jul: Wise up to clear credit card debt
     07 May: Ways to prepare for the unexpected
     30 Mar: Time for a financial progress check
     10 Feb: Studying up on NZ Super
     10 Jan: Managing the back-to-school bills
     Top Stories

    New Zealand Rugby boss Mark Robinson is refusing to shed any light on the future of coach Ian Foster More...

    New Zealand Rugby boss Mark Robinson is refusing to shed any light on the future of coach Ian Foster More...

     Today's News

    Law and Order:
    Search teams in Rotorua are reviewing their next steps after still finding no sign of missing kayaker Gregory Flavell 21:49

    Accident and Emergency:
    One person has died in a crash on Kopu-Hikaui Road, near the Tairua River Bridge on Coromandel Peninsulaar 21:29

    Three lion cubs born in Nama zoo are a rare, joyous sight in war-scarred Gaza 21:09

    A political commentator thinks Sam Uffindell hasn't had any consequences for his past actions 18:59

    A New Zealand psychologist says we need smart solutions to tackle youth crime 18:39

    French climate activists fill golf course holes with cement, protesting against water ban exemption amid drought 18:09

    New Zealand Rugby boss Mark Robinson is refusing to shed any light on the future of coach Ian Foster 18:09

    North Harbour lead Manawatu in the second half of their NPC outing in Auckland 17:29

    The Black Caps look unshakeable heading into their final dead rubber twenty20 against the West Indies tomorrow morning 17:09

    Law and Order:
    Auckland have survived against a valiant Southland outfit for a 24-23 NPC victory in Invercargill 16:49

     News Search

    Power Search

    © 2022 New Zealand City Ltd