News | National
14 Oct 2024 13:05
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • Crime.co.nz
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > National

    Ads from Hell: how a pizza brand’s marketing reveals NZ’s shifting religious attitudes

    Ads for the Hell Pizza chain regularly invite complaints on religious grounds. But none have been upheld, reflecting more tolerant standards in an increasingly less Christian country.

    Dan Fastnedge, Lecturer in Advertising and Brand Creativity, Auckland University of Technology, Melissa L. Gould, Head of Critical Media Studies and Senior Lecturer, Auckland University of Technology
    The Conversation


    Controversial advertising holds a mirror up to society. It can unite us in laughter or outrage, spark debates that shape our beliefs – and sometimes expose our political differences.

    But where do lines of acceptability or offensiveness get drawn? Earlier this year the New Zealand Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) announced the most complained about ads ever.

    Categories ranged from political advocacy to household products. And the most complained about spot belonged to Hell Pizza’s “Lust condom” mailers. The brand’s “Hell Crossed Buns” billboard came in third.

    This is not surprising, given the brand is often in the headlines for its provocative campaigns. Controversy is clearly part of the marketing strategy.

    But while multiple complaints might suggest widespread public criticism, our research wanted to test the changing relationship between religious belief and advertising standards: what offends New Zealanders, what pushes the boundaries, and when does an ad cross the line of “acceptable” controversy?

    Religious offence vs artistic freedom

    Of the 79 ASA rulings between 2005 and 2021 regarding Hell Pizza, only six were upheld in full, and two were partially upheld. This suggests that while Hell’s ads generate strong public reactions, the majority of its advertising follows established guidelines.

    About 40% of the rulings responded to complaints containing religious objections, but no complaints were upheld on religious grounds.

    The complainants often identified as Christian, or said they were commenting on behalf of a religious audience. They described Hell’s ads variously as “nothing short of emotional and spiritual abuse”, “grossly offensive”, “sickening”, “distasteful”, “discriminatory and insensitive” and “blasphemous”.

    The ASA acknowledged Hell’s ads would naturally weave religious puns and references into their narrative, as humour is part of the company’s branding. But it ruled these “align within the boundaries of acceptable humour and satire in a tolerant society”.

    Hell crossed buns: called ‘offensive’ and ‘blasphemous’ but complaints not upheld.

    The “Hell Crossed Buns” billboards racked up 178 complaints. The inclusion of a pentagram was described as “extremely offensive”, with the use of a Satanic symbol combined with the ad copy called “blasphemous” – particularly in the lead up to Easter.

    The ASA responded that it was “a satirical play on commonly recognised religious imagery, which helped it stay within the bounds of artistic freedom”. The complaints were not upheld.

    Hell Pizza’s 2014 Easter-themed billboard covered in rabbit skin (promoting its “rabbit pizza”) also received complaints for being disrespectful to religious groups and vegans.

    While acknowledging the billboard might upset children, the ASA said it was “unlikely to cause serious and widespread offence to most people”, as rabbits are considered a pest and the skins were sourced from a local meat processor. The complaints were not upheld.

    Rabbit pizza: ‘unlikely to cause serious and widespread offence’.

    Crossing the line

    The ASA has upheld complaints about eight Hell Pizza ads between 2005 and 2021, primarily those focused on profanity, graphic violence, racism or sexual themes, rather than religion.

    The “most hated New Zealand campaign in history” was Hell’s “Lust” campaign from 2006, when the company delivered condoms to 170,000 homes to promote their Lust pizza.

    The outrage mainly centered around the potential for children to be exposed to the unsolicited delivery of a condom. The ASA said that despite the message of safe sex having some merit, the campaign was “likely to offend a number of communities”. The complaints were upheld.

    But while religion has been the main focus of the complaints against Hell’s ads, those that were upheld were not because of religious factors.

    ‘Lust’ condom promotion: ‘likely to offend a number of communities’.

    In fact, it was the “religious identity” of the pizza franchise that was often cited by the ASA as the reason why the controversial ads weren’t breaching advertising standards. That is, people should expect Hell Pizza campaigns to be dark, edgy and shocking.

    Although the brand frequently walks the line between provocative humour and possible offence, the ASA rulings indicate a shift towards supporting artistic freedom – even when religious themes are involved, and especially for brands with a strong, established identity.

    Shifting trends and boundaries

    This shift reflects changes in New Zealand society: a decline in people self-identifying as Christian, an increasing number self-identifying as agnostic or not religious, and those who do identify as religious belonging to a more diverse range of faiths.

    Hell Pizza has successfully tapped into this cultural trend by pushing boundaries that previously might have sparked even more outrage.

    Pushing boundaries: how will social issue humour play in a polarised world?

    The brand has also mastered the art of grabbing attention and media coverage that would have been impossible with only traditional paid-advertising techniques.

    By inciting public debate, generating complaints and making headlines, it has built a brand identity that thrives on the backlash, using it to fuel further visibility and discussion.

    How the strategy works when applied to social issues in an increasingly polarised world remains to be seen. But Hell’s recent “Go to Hell Greta” billboards in Stockholm, as well as its blood-based “to-meat-o sauce” and “AfterLife Pay” offerings, suggest the company will continue to push boundaries.

    How religious complaints compare to ones concerned with other social issues, and what this tells us about changing moral and ethical attitudes, will be the focus of our next research project.

    The Conversation

    The authors do not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and have disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

    This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license.
    © 2024 TheConversation, NZCity

     Other National News
     14 Oct: A 50-year-old man will face court today - accused of failing to stop for police and abandoning his vehicle on Auckland's North Shore last night
     14 Oct: Confidence there's progress on Queenstown's housing crisis
     14 Oct: UN peacekeepers at risk as they deliver protection for civilians in southern Lebanon
     14 Oct: Atmospheric rivers are shifting poleward, reshaping global weather patterns
     14 Oct: The Voice defeat set us all back. And since then, our leaders have given up
     14 Oct: 30 years ago, Tarantino’s Pulp Fiction shook Hollywood and redefined ‘cool’ cinema
     14 Oct: Two of the teenage victims of a single-vehicle crash, which ploughed into Marlborough's Tuamarina River, are being farewelled today
     Top Stories

    RUGBY RUGBY
    A shock in the last NPC quarterfinal in Blenheim.. More...


    BUSINESS BUSINESS
    New Zealand could be pricing itself out of the benefits of a busy cruise ship season More...



     Today's News

    Entertainment:
    Ethel Kennedy has died at the age of 96 12:36

    Netball:
    The Silver Ferns are getting up to speed with Australia's physical style of play in training camp ahead of the Constellation Cup netball series, starting Sunday 12:27

    Politics:
    Middle East war live updates: Four Israeli soldiers killed after Hezbollah drones evade Iron Dome, Gaza health officials say 20 killed in air strike 12:17

    Entertainment:
    Sean 'Diddy' Combs will face a sex trafficking trial in May 2025 12:06

    Cricket:
    In a bizarre rarity, the England and Pakistan cricketers may continue using the first test pitch for the second match in Multan starting tomorrow 11:57

    Law and Order:
    A 50-year-old man will face court today - accused of failing to stop for police and abandoning his vehicle on Auckland's North Shore last night 11:57

    Law and Order:
    Cordons are up on a North Waikato road - where a man was found with critical injuries about 2.30 this morning 11:47

    Entertainment:
    Paula Abdul is "recovering well" after a series of injuries forced her to cancel her tour 11:36

    Politics:
    Confidence there's progress on Queenstown's housing crisis 11:27

    National:
    UN peacekeepers at risk as they deliver protection for civilians in southern Lebanon 11:17


     News Search






    Power Search


    © 2024 New Zealand City Ltd