News | National
8 Nov 2024 1:55
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • Crime.co.nz
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > National

    Trump and Harris are sharply divided on science, but share common ground on US technology policy

    Based on federal budgeting requests from the past 2 administrations, Trump and Harris placed different values on science research funding.

    Kenneth Evans, Scholar in Science and Technology Policy, Baker Institute for Public Policy, Rice University
    The Conversation


    For the first time in American history, quantum computing was mentioned by a candidate during a presidential debate, on Sept. 10, 2024. After Vice President Kamala Harris brought up quantum technology, she and former President Donald Trump went on to have a heated back-and-forth about American chipmaking and China’s rise in semiconductor manufacturing. Science and technology policy usually takes a back seat to issues such as immigration, the economy and health care during election season.

    What’s changed for 2024?

    From COVID-19 to climate change, ChatGPT to, yes, quantum computers, science-related issues are on the minds of American policymakers and voters alike. The federal government spends nearly US$200 billion each year on scientific research and development to address these challenges and many others. Presidents and Congress, however, rarely agree on how – and how much – money should be spent on science.

    With the increasing public focus on global competitiveness, the climate crisis and artificial intelligence, a closer look at Trump’s and Harris’ records on science and technology policy could provide a hint about how they’d approach these topics if elected this fall.

    Two distinct visions for science funding

    If politics can be described as “who gets what and when,” U.S. science and technology policy can be assessed through the annual budget process for R&D. By this measure, the differences between the Trump and Biden-Harris administrations couldn’t be starker.

    In his first budget request to Congress, in 2017, Trump spurned decades of precedent, proposing historic cuts across nearly every federal science agency. In particular, Trump targeted climate-related programs at the Department of Energy, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration and the Environmental Protection Agency.

    Trump’s fiscal policy took a page from Reagan-era conservative orthodoxy, prioritizing military spending over social programs, including R&D. Unlike Reagan, however, Trump also took aim at basic research funding, an area with long-standing bipartisan support in Congress. His three subsequent budget proposals were no different: across-the-board reductions to federal research programs, while pushing for increases to defense technology development and demonstration projects.

    Congress rebuked nearly all of Trump’s requests. Instead, it passed some of the largest increases to federal R&D programs in U.S. history, even before accounting for emergency spending packages funded as part of the government’s pandemic response.

    In contrast, the Biden-Harris administration made science and innovation a centerpiece of its early policy agenda – with budgets to match. Leveraging the slim Democratic majority during the 117th Congress, Biden and Harris shepherded three landmark bills into law: the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, the Inflation Reduction Act and the CHIPS and Science Act. These laws contain significant R&D provisions focused on environmental projects (IIJA), clean energy (IRA) and American semiconductor manufacturing (CHIPS).

    CHIPS set up programs within the National Science Foundation and the Department of Commerce to create regional technology hubs in support of American manufacturing. The act also set ambitious funding targets for federal science agencies, especially at NSF, calling for its budget to be doubled from $9 billion to over $18 billion over the course of five years.

    Despite its initial push for R&D, the Biden-Harris administration’s final two budget proposals offered far less to science. Years of deficit spending and a new Republican majority in the House cast a cloud of budget austerity over Congress. Instead of moving toward doubling NSF’s budget, the agency suffered an 8% decrease in fiscal year 2024 – its biggest cut in over three decades. For FY2025, which runs from Oct. 1, 2024, through Sept. 30, 2025, Biden and Harris requested a meager 3% increase for NSF, billions of dollars short of CHIPS-enacted spending levels.

    An emerging consensus on China

    On technology policy, Biden and Harris share more with Trump than they let on.

    Their approach to competing with China on tech follows Trump’s lead: They’ve expanded tariffs on Chinese goods and severely limited China’s access to American-made computer chips and semiconductor manufacturing equipment.

    Biden and Harris have also ramped up research security efforts intended to protect U.S. ideas and innovation from China. Trump launched the China Initiative as an attempt to stop the Chinese government from stealing American research. The Biden-Harris administration ended the program in 2022, but pieces of it remain in place. Scientific collaborations between the United States and China continue to decline, to the detriment of American scientific leadership.

    people in white coats and head coverings work on a Chinese semiconductor assembly line
    Semiconductor manufacturing is a key to many technologies; by extension, where it happens can be a security issue. Costfoto/NurPhoto via Getty Images

    The Biden-Harris administration has also drawn from Trump-era policy to strengthen America’s leadership in “industries of the future.” The term, coined by Trump’s then-chief science adviser Kelvin Droegemeier, refers to five emerging technology areas: AI, quantum science, advanced manufacturing, advanced communications and biotechnology. This language has been parroted by the Biden-Harris administration as part of its focus on American manufacturing and throughout Harris’ campaign, including during the debate.

    In short, both candidates align with the emerging Washington bipartisan consensus on China: innovation policy at home, strategic decoupling abroad.

    Science advice not always a welcome resource

    Trump’s dismissal of and at times outright contempt for scientific consensus is well documented. From “Sharpiegate,” when he mapped his own projected path for Hurricane Dorian, to pulling out of the Paris climate agreement, World Health Organization and the Iran nuclear deal, Trump has demonstrated an unwillingness to accept any advice, let alone from scientists.

    Indeed, Trump took over two years to hire Droegemeier as director of the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy, or OSTP, doubling the previous record for the length of time a president has gone without a scientific adviser. This absence was no doubt reflected in Trump’s short-on-science budget requests to Congress, especially during the beginning of his administration.

    On the other hand, the Biden-Harris administration has promoted science and innovation as a core part of its broader economic policy agenda. It elevated the role of OSTP: Biden is the first president to name his science adviser – a position currently held by Arati Prabhakar – as a member of his Cabinet.

    By law, the president is required to appoint an OSTP director. But it is up to the president to decide how and when to use their advice. If the new White House wants the U.S. to remain a global leader in R&D, the science adviser will need to continue to fight for it.

    The Conversation

    Kenneth Evans receives funding from the National Science Foundation, the American Institute of Physics, and the Clinton Foundation. He is affiliated with Rice University and Rice University's Baker Institute for Public Policy.

    This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license.
    © 2024 TheConversation, NZCity

     Other National News
     07 Nov: Three people have been injured - one seriously - after a two vehicle crash on Pyes Pa Road, between Tauranga and Rotorua, about 2.40pm
     07 Nov: A barefoot man on a bike could hold clues to a suspicious fire at a block of Lower Hutt flats this week
     07 Nov: A third Christchurch-based bid for an NRL franchise license has been launched, valued at 360 million dollars
     07 Nov: Henry Hill School and Porritt School in Napier - remain in lockdown, after Police were called to Tait Drive with reports of a person with a firearm
     07 Nov: Abortion did not play as big a role in the US election as many anticipated. What might happen on this issue now?
     07 Nov: A person's in custody - after ambulance staff reported seeing a possible firearm, as they took a patient to Auckland's Waitakere Hospital
     07 Nov: America’s glass ceiling remains - here are some of the reasons why a woman may have once again lost the presidency
     Top Stories

    RUGBY RUGBY
    Ireland coach Andy Farrell has put the heartbreak of last year's World Cup quarter-final out of his mind ahead of a rematch against the All Blacks on Saturday morning More...


    BUSINESS BUSINESS
    A third Christchurch-based bid for an NRL franchise license has been launched, valued at 360 million dollars More...



     Today's News

    Motoring:
    In basketball's NBA, the Cleveland Cavaliers have set a franchise record in going unbeaten through their first nine games of the season, after downing the Pelicans on the road 21:57

    Entertainment:
    Dolly Parton wants the royal family to visit Dollywood 21:55

    Entertainment:
    Sarah, Duchess of York and her daughters Princesses Beatrice and Eugenie call themselves "the tripod" 21:25

    Accident and Emergency:
    Three people have been injured - one seriously - after a two vehicle crash on Pyes Pa Road, between Tauranga and Rotorua, about 2.40pm 21:17

    International:
    Germany in political disarray after ruling coalition collapses hours after US election 21:07

    Entertainment:
    Holly Madison has claimed Pamela Anderson was standoffish with the other Playboy Bunnies in the company of Hugh Hefner 20:55

    Entertainment:
    Amanda Seyfried says moving out of Los Angeles was "essential for my mental health" 20:25

    Entertainment:
    Ariana Grande wanted to "honour" her younger self with her credit in 'Wicked' 19:55

    International:
    Donald Trump is the first convicted felon to be president of the United States and his re-election could thwart further criminal cases against him 19:27

    Entertainment:
    Selena Gomez says it's been a "challenge" for people to "accept" that she has "moved on" with her career 19:25


     News Search






    Power Search


    © 2024 New Zealand City Ltd